Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

[KBS2 Drama 2015] Who Are You: School 2015 (후아유: 학교 2015) Official Thread


Chakras

Recommended Posts

Random comment but...

I found it so touching that scene when it showed 1 year before and EunByul was talking to Yi Ahn about having a twin sister and how he felt about it.

Then she added about hanging out together and everything. It showed how much Eunbyul cared about her sister and wanted her close. And also she kept sending gifts to EunBi so she would know someone cared about her.

Of course her last action saving EunBi from death was the biggest of all.

I find it so touching. I hope Eunbyul is alive and they can finally meet!

 

I also think so. I want to see their sisterhood even more because of this. I hope Eun Byul will be back  :rlytearpls:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm getting more curious on who outed So Young and spreaded rumors about her (which is actually true). We all know now for sure now that it's not either Eun Bi or Tae Kwang. It must be someone who knew the truth yet sided with Eun Bi all this time, or hated So Young. Considering these, there isn't someone I can think of even if it's a new character. There's no way Jung In Young (student teacher) sided with Eun Bi/Eun Byul since it's obvious she hates her and has grudge on her. The only one I can think of doing that is Eun Byul, thus it makes the probability of Eun Byul being alive is higher. If not her, who else?? Even if there's a new character that has yet to be introduced who did that, I can't imagine what's the relationship between that new character and Eun Bi or So Young to do that, also how that new character gets to know the past of both of them. Eun Byul is all I can think of right now.

Thus I expect Eun Byul to come out anytime unexpectedly, or I expect another new character to be introduced, too (my bet is more on Eun Byul though).

 

 

 

 

Nam Joo Hyuk's acting just isn't cutting it for me. :unsure:  The scene where he finds out EunByul is dead and sees her ashes was not convincing nor sad at all. He was a pretty decent actor in Surplus Princess but his acting in comparison to Kim So Hyun and Sungjae's and most of the other cast is lacking a lot.

 

 

 

 

I also think so. I agree that I'm not convinced of his sadness at all especially when Eun Byul is supposed to be someone he loves and his friend of 10 years. It feels so underwhelming.

I've been criticizing his acting objectively ever since ep 1 and and sincerely hope he would improve over time, but he didn't improve significantly especially on emotional scenes. Yet I was accused I criticized him because they thought I'm an EunKwang shipper so I criticized him subjectively. God please  :imstupid:

Edited by riribl
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What about the girl who Eunbi stood up for? I mean, she knew the history between Eunbi and So Young. She might believe that Eunbi actually died and she might have known that So Young transferred to Sekang so this could be her way of revenge or something.

 

I dunno. I think I'm becoming a delulu.

 

​I've thought about the possibility of that girl before, but it seems like a bit of a stretch considering the rumors were spreaded at Sekang school in Seoul which is pretty far away from her school at Tong Yeong. She didn't even help Eun Bi when Eun Bi was stripped by So Young gang in front of her eyes, let alone be bothered to do that. When So Young was forced to be expelled from her school she might think it's enough already and doesn't concern herself over So Young matter anymore.

Imo there needs to be someone who holds a pretty big grudge against So Young to be doing that, and that leads me to Eun Byul.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who Are You: School 2015
shafjhds.jpg
 
tv Report - Naver: 'Who Are You' Kim Soo Hyun's bullying past a huge shock to Nam Joo Hyuk
 

1. [+10466, -334] It's impossible not to fall in love with Gong Tae Kwang

2. [+7834, -63] What is up with that female teacher?..... She freaks me out

3. [+1475, -25] The car accident is quite makjang ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹

4. [+880, -23] Is Han Yi Ahn some kind of a superhero? Why is he normal after he got hit by a car?

5. [+841, -10] The female teacher is the dead student's sister. She's in the school to get revenge

6. [+764, -20] She should just reveal that they're twins. Lee Eun Bi is frustrating

7. [+511, -7] I like strong female leads like  Lee Bo Young's character in 'I Hear Your Voice'. She's so sassy and fearless. Lee Eun Bi needs to show that strong side of her

7. [+301, -5] Gong Tae Kwang's dad will probably help Eun Bi

8. [+372, -14] Gong Tae Kwang made my heart flutter today

 

Credit: kkuljaem

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That girl was probably afraid of receiving the same BS when she was already living a normal life that's why she decided not to stick her nose in SY's business anymor. That doesn't mean she didn't feel any ounce of guilt. Eunbi's suicide was probably her driving force to out SY's secret. I mean, Eunbi stood up for her and she didn't do a thing and now that she's dead, it must have been haunting her the way Eunbyeol was haunted with her memories with Soo In. And the fact that SY is in Seoul is all the more reason for her to gather her courage because she knows that SY can't lift a finger on her anymore. The fact that Tongyeong is way far from Seoul makes her the least likely to become a suspect.

 

Even with that imo the girl seems to be too weak-willed to do that especially considering her school is far from So Young's current school. For some reasons I think there needs to be some more motivation for her to do that, especially considering she's not close with Eun Bi. Moreover what I'm wondering about is even if she's the one who did that, how did she spread the rumors? She's not even in that school and her actual school is far away from there. Hmm.

 

 

Earlier in the first breakout, someone on another forum suspected Minjoon. He read clipped news pieces every morning and his mother pressured him to excel the transfer student.

 

When teacher Kim talked to Minjoon that lie would make one a coward, I think he talked about himself. He lied in Sooin's case and he who couldn't confess was a coward.

 

Oh right I forgot about him. But how did he get to know the girl the article was talking about is So Young? Even after So Young denied it the rumor spreader seems to be sure that her identity is the same with the talked article, unless he's just taking a wild bet.

But so far I think Min Joon is more possible than the girl whom Eun Bi stood up for, though.

Edited by riribl
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wanted to quote more ppl but it started to get too much  :derp:

 

I agree since ep1 with all those that said Nam JooHyuk's acting sucks. I thought Minho was bad (I'm going to get negged for this) but man... he makes Minho look good.  

 

I don't think those who like Eunkwang are being harsh on NJH's acting at all but using his acting to be harsh on YiAhn...  Sure, YiAhn isn't perfect but he's a nice guy.  I think most Eunkwang shippers forget that Taekwang practically started a relationship with Eunbi from scratch - a white piece of paper, while YiAhn had 8yrs of history.  Taekwang obviously doesn't give a crap about whether Eunbyul is alive or not cause she probably feels the same about him.  Hence, it's easier for him to accept Eunbi isn't Eunbyul (and doesn't care that Eunbyul is dead)  :imstupid:

 

Does anyone think Eunbyul might have died because of her respiratory problems?  Perhaps, that's why she could never compete nor train to be a pro swimmer?  She exerted too much energy trying to save Eunbi?  IDK, at this point if she's still alive I think it would be even more makjang because how has she managed her living expenses?

 

I don't know about others but I never did dislike Yi Ahn. I just don't approve some of his actions in ep 8. 

Also the reason why I'm against Yi Ahn ending up with Eun Bi is not because I dislike Yi Ahn nor I think Yi Ahn is a bad guy, but the circumstances they're in make them unsuitable and too makjang to get together. If only they got together Eun Bi would live being loved in her sister's shadow forever especially considering she has the same face (but different personality) and Yi Ahn used to love her twin sister for a long time. It's not easy for Yi Ahn to see Eun Bi for Eun Bi without being reminded by Eun Byul especially when they have the same face, Eun Byul is his first love and 10 years childhood friend after all. How sucks it is to be loved in the shadow of someone else forever. I really don't like those kind of circumstances thus I prefer them to not be together.

I don't really ship EunKwang but I do prefer Tae Kwang ending up with Eun Bi much more than Yi Ahn because of Yi Ahn - Eun Bi circumstances. 

Despite that I do think that NJH's lacking ability in acting out Yi Ahn doesn't bring out Yi Ahn character's charm to the maximum potential, since I think if only Yi Ahn was acted well Yi Ahn's charm would appeal more to people and more people would sympathize with him definitely.

 

Now that you mentioned about it, I think I recall vaguely that Eun Byul could never compete to be a pro swimmer, but I forgot what the reason is.

 

 

 

Wait. I just noticed that the preview showed Minjoon looking at the homepage, probably typing something...

 

It could really be him!

 

 

Way to go, Minjoon! If you're going down, might as well drag some psycho bitch with you. Lol.

 

 

I just noticed when I watched the preview again. It's most probably him then.

Edited by riribl
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I see your point and I hope if the writers do make them end up together it's not for those reasons.  I personally would prefer it to be like 2013 and no one really ends up together considering it's just HS.

 

I don't think Eunbyul had much of a character development or the writer's seem to jump from letting us know what the real Eunbyul was like to love triangle.  I am still quite annoyed by it no offence to Eunbi but I'd like to know more about her and Eunbyul.  I'm only speculating since little Eunbyul said she could never win a medal for swimming and that flashback scene she couldn't stand the fluffy toy YiAhn was shaking in front of her.  The place Eunbi jumped into seem quite deep so it would of exhausted Eunbyul quite a lot even though she was a good swimmer.

 

This plot of Soyong? revealing Eunbi. I bet I spelt her name wrong,  I'm not good at remembering Korean names.. Anyhow, this plot has been going on for so many episodes I hope they don't rush how Eunbyul died and the SooIn incident that we have still yet to figure out.  Assuming ep10 is still about revealing Eunbi's real identity, there's really only 4eps left to know about Eunbyul and SooIn.  :cry:

 

I prefer Eun Bi to not end up with anyone than with Yi Ahn. Eun Bi has been living a hard life all this time she deserves to be loved as herself without another girl's shadow.

If Yi Ahn easily turns to Eun Bi it makes the story even more makjang and it's just a poor script writing. No matter what Eun Bi has the very same face with Eun Byul, Yi Ahn would be reminded by his love for Eun Byul everytime he sees Eun Bi, forever. Thus please writer don't write it this way.

 

I feel like if only Yi Ahn - Eun Bi circumstances were different (without the twin switch thing and Yi Ahn likes Eun Bi from the beginning), I would be rooting for Yi Ahn more definitely. Yi Ahn is more like my type of guy anyway. 

 

 

Why only 4 episodes left? There's still 6 episodes left. I hope they won't rush the mystery revelation in the ending and will pace it evenly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your sig is life. :stare:  I surprised no one has really talked about this scene much. Most has been Yian superhero talk lol. I really liked that scene and I was waiting for it since episode 6. It carries so much significance-just four syllables. "Hi Lee Eun Bi." Taekwang I love you. Probably my favorite scene from the drama so far.

 

I was a bit baffled with Yian this episode actually. I just thought he'd be more affected by Eunbyul's death. He was upset but definitely not the reaction I expected. I thought he'd have some sort of breakdown but he seemed pretty calm when he went to the cemetery. Just...I mean a 10 year friend? I'd be a mess. Idk if the existence of Eunbi made a difference in his reaction? But that kinda makes me feel bad for Eunbyul. /i dont even know what im saying now

 

Imo I think the person who 'leaks' the stuff about SY is either Minjoon or Eunbyul. I can't decide between the two though.

 

I also think so. Idk if it's because NJH's lacking ability to deliver or the script is written like that. Probably those scenes could deliver how much he's sad of it if only it's acted out well, you know from expressions and body languages. Idk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Omg you guys are tempting me so much. However I'm gonna faithfully wait for the subbed one to actually watch ep 10.

 

 

 

Hi everyone i'm new here...so i still at ep 6 today with eng sub. Just wanna know if that sooin(?) Is dead really? And wjat is her relationship woth eunbyeol?

Also forgive me to say this but i hope the writers wont mess the plot cause the story is really good but i have seen a lot of good plot gotwasted because the ending is either made in a hurry or messed up. I hope that eunbyeol is still alive becuase i feel bad to ian not knowing the truth and will hve him feel guilty at the end cause he was the last to know the truth. If eunbyeol is dead...i dont really know who to ship eunbi.

 

Soo In is confirmed as dead. Her relationship with Eun Byul is still questionable.

I also sincerely hope the story won't be messed up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a gut feeling on what the plot twist is but I'll keep it for myself and keep low expectation of it to actually happen for now.

 

 

Ah ok. Then someone who know about the soo in incident must have been stirring the people involved in the incident...but i wonder why their teacher was soo shocked when he saw eubi sleeping at hr desk then a flashback of soo in appeared...did he do something bad before that he was so shocked?

 

It hasn't been revealed why up until ep 9.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yess! My gut feelings is right! Eun Byul is alive!

I'm so excited to see the turn of events when she comes back. I can't wait to see her sisterhood with Eun Bi and when Eun Byul will kick So Young's ass for her. I hope there will be sensible explanation on how Eun Byul was hiding, the corpse, etc. Right now I'm just happy that Eun Byul is alive. I actually like her personality (maybe I like her more than Eun Bi, because Eun Bi practically cries every episode and is so soft-hearted) so I'm excited for her comeback. Girl is too cool to be dead just like that.

 

 

About the shipping, Eun Byul does like Yi Ahn. Yi Ahn likes Eun Byul a lot, a 10-years first love doesn't simply go away. To me maybe Yi Ahn has a bit of feelings to Eun Bi but it doesn't even compare to the feelings he has for Eun Byul. 

So unlike some people, by now I highly doubt Yi Ahn will end up with Eun Bi. Eun Bi knows those facts of them liking each other clearly. So although she has developed feelings for Yi Ahn, considering those facts, the fact that Eun Byul saved her, and she got to enjoy the luxury of life thanks to Eun Byul, I say 90% chance Eun Bi will step out out of their relationship and gives up. Also Tae Kwang is there for her anyway.

 

I've always liked Eun Byul - Yi Ahn dynamic more than Eun Bi - Yi Ahn, so I definitely want to see it again when Eun Byul comes back  :smile:

 

 

I'm keeping my stand on my theory that Yi Ahn will NOT end up with Eunbi. 

 

Join my cult. Watch me be right.

 

I join you.

 

 

 

Btw it cracks me up how Tae Kwang cockblocked in every occasions and got all jealous by himself. His cockblocking skill is no joke lol

Edited by riribl
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[spoilers] School 2015 Ep 10


 


sfajkfdjks.jpg


 


Osen - Naver: 'Who Are You' Kim Hee Jung declines offer to become a celebrity, "I don't want to betray my friend"

 


1. [+1763, -12] That's really cool of Seung Joo!!!!!

 

2. [+1308, -10] Go Eun Byul is alive

 

3. [+1116, -10] Daebak?!!!!!!! Eun Byul is alive ã… ã… ã… ã… ã… ã… 

 

4. [+100, -1] I wonder what's gonna happen with the plot if Eun Byul is really alive. I'm rooting for Eun Bi and Han Yi Ahn 

 

 

Star News - Naver: 'Who Are You' records best rating so far at 7.1%... doubled in just a month

 

5. [+3636, -36] As the ratings increase, the viewers' anger level towards So Young goes up too 

 

6. [+2907, -106] This is such a good drama but so few people are watching itㅜㅜ

 

7. [+272, -10] This is honestly more fun than 'Hwajung' 

 

8. [+139, -3] Heol daebak. I was worried at first because of possible acting controversy. I hope the ratings increase more

 

9. [+107, -3] If this  drama  had secured more viewers at the start, I'm pretty sure the ratings would be even higher. I'm 25 years old and my heart flutters for these high school kids ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹

 

10.  [+86, 0] Three weeks left to go. I'm sad 

 

Credit: kkuljaem

Edited by riribl
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm surprised how happy and excited I am now that Eun Byul is alive. I think it's mainly because I like Eun Byul's characters more than Eun Bi, especially after Eun Bi cried practically in every episode and was too soft-hearted. Eun Byul is more on the tough and confident side so I like her better so far. I can't wait for her to actually come out and see what she's going to do about the whole circumstances. I also wanna know everything about her disappearance, what she's doing during those times, her reasons, everything.

The second reason is because I wanna see her sisterhood with Eun Bi. I wonder how they will react once they meet each other and what they're going to do. Also what Eun Byul is going to do when she met So Young by herself.

Last reason is because I wanna see her reuniting with Yi Ahn. I like her dynamic with Yi Ahn and they actually fit each other, so I wanna see them reuniting and ending up together.

 

Now that Eun Byul is revealed as being alive, are you guys positive that the one who spreaded rumors at Sekang school was Eun Byul? I guess it's most probably her then.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I feel the same, Eun Byul was at Toyeong, she probably investigated what happened with Eun Bi, and when she knew that So young was in Sakang with Eun Bi wanted to reveil the bullying thing before So Young tried to harm more her sister.

The thing i want to know is how Eun Byul knows that So Young is in Sekang, has she been spying her school or maybe has an accomplice?

 

Although Eun Byul was spotted at the cemetery at Tongyeong, it hasn't been sure whether Eun Byul kept staying there during her disappearance or went to Seoul before. 

If only Eun Byul kept staying at Tongyeong, Eun Byul probably got to know where So Young transferred to from rumors at the previous school. I'm also wondering whether the execution of rumors spreading is possible without an accomplice or not. Considering the time frame of the school homepage being updated and all students accessing it with the time when the rumor was posted on the homepage matched, I guess it's possible for Eun Byul to have an accomplice. But just who??

 

The only person I can think of having the most possibility so far is Shi Jin. She's the last person who met Eun Byul after all, and she's close enough with Eun Byul. Who knows maybe Shi Jin told a lie about the restroom incident in order to cover up Eun Byul's plan to disappear. Idk it's just a wild speculation.

Edited by riribl
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tbh, I'd love to see it, too. But... lol, idk why my mind keep thinking about how its hard to make it happen.

Besides the reason that I already said (they need to explain so many things about Eunbyul), theres one other reason.

The actress for Eunbyul and Eunbi is the same person, Kim So Hyun. So, when you said about 'sisterhood', idk why, but my mind instantly jumped there. "Can they do well for the filming and editing, in case they want to show a scene like that?"

Idk, maybe bcuz I rarely saw a movie or tv series like this before (maybe except hollywood's action movies), maybe thats why I keep wondering about this everytime someone mentioned Eunbyul and Eunbi.

 

As for the ship, I think I'll join the cult, too. Im not even sure if Eunbi has serious feelings for Yi Ahn. I think its more of guilty feeling than romantic feeling, atleast for now. 

And somehow, I like Yi Ahn's reaction to Eunbi in ep 10. Bcus its understandable. If he accept Eunbi so fast, it wont make sense. Especially bcus the only thing he know is that Eunbyul died for saving Eunbi.

 

Kang SoYoung was really stupid, lol. This is why I never felt scared even if shes gonna reveal everything to the class, bcus just like Taekwang said, the reaction from the class will be very predictable. If Eunbi is not dead, and Eunbyul died in her place instead, then basically SoYoung was the reason why Eunbyul died. Ofcourse Yi Ahn will be so mad at her, more than how he will be mad at Eunbi. Lol, her grades are good, but she cant think about that. So stupid.

 

Have you watched Reply 1994? In Reply 1994 there are some scenes when Sung Dong Il had to play 2 roles, Sung Dong Il 1 and Sung Dong Il 2 met each other and they hang out together. And somehow they made those scenes believable as if there really are 2 Sung Dong Ils hanging out together LOL So if they could do it, I'm sure School 2015 can do it too. I'm sure the production team has calculated it from the beginning considering the twins premise and if there are some scenes when Eun Byul and Eun Bi have to be together.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

spoilers/theories from k-fans:

 

"Anyone read about the spoilers from kfans? 

Apparently it was Eunbyul who went to see Yihan at the hospital the first time. There are photos in the third page of the comments sections, you have to click the green button to see the whole post first."

http://www.instiz.net/pt/2937670&green=1&page=1&grnpage=3&greenset=

 

 

here's the picture:

 

 

bfe23417e6e6894134573a61105293ed.jpg

 

 

 

How did they come to that conclusion?? o_O I'm really curious.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have no idea lol. Wish I could understand Korean and translate their comments on that post. 

 

 

I don't agree with them though, I think the girl in that picture is Eun Bi.

 

Wait I just read the comment and I do understand Korean a bit. It says because on that pic the girl has a wound on her neck so she/he thinks she's Eun Byul.

I don't see any wound though. Or was it because the pic was bad quality? From the LQ one it does seem like something plastered on her neck, or it's just an illusion out of her hair lol

And the responses after that post is exactly talking about it seems like an illusion from her hair lol

Edited by riribl
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmm then it most likely isn't her.

 

I'm interested to see how much Eun Byul has been keeping tabs on Eun Bi and everything that has happened at the school since her disappearance. I'm also curious as to why she wanted to disappear in the first place. Maybe with her "dead" and her sister in her place she would be able to secretly search for the person pretending to be Soo In ??

If Eun Byul is the one who spreaded the rumors, it's most likely she has an accomplice inside of the school, and it's even highly possible it's someone from class 2-3 too considering the recent school homepage thing. If that's the case Eun Byul might be keeping tabs on Eun Bi and everything that has happened in school from that very accomplice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You're probably right but since ep 1 (I think), she was already jealous of Eunbyul.  You could see how left out and jealous she felt when Song Joo & Eunbyul wore the same shoes and backpack.  At first I thought it was because she wasn't included but then came So Young.  She was super jealous and upset when she saw how close they were at the makeup store.  So I have doubts about her helping Eunbyul.  

 

Or maybe she's upset that Song Joo chose to abandon Eunbyul and be close to So Young, IDK.  This writer is good with the other plots besides the romance bit I'll have to admit  :smile:

 

Yeah that's what made me doubt of my theory. But besides her I can't think of anyone else unless the story reveals Eun Byul has some sort of secret relationship with another student of class 2-3 later.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmm what about the class pres? In ep 1 wasnt he the one who saw shi ahn go out of the bathroom?

 

Eun Byul isn't close to Min Joon though and I don't think Min Joon is the type whom Eun Byul wants to be close to either. Min Joon also might think Eun Byul as his academic rival, so low chance it's him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In another forum there's someone who speculated that the girl whom Eun Bi stood up for might be working together with Eun Byul.

 

Now that I think about it, it makes sense if that's the case. When Eun Bi went from school to the bridge to commit suicide after she's being humiliated by SY, it's possible that the girl who witnessed that humiliation followed her out of guilt, then she happened to witness Eun Bi jumping from the bridge because of that. Eun Byul was there on the bridge saving Eun Bi as well, so it's possible for them to meet up for the first time at that time.

 

If Eun Byul does work together with her, perhaps that girl was the one who gave Eun Byul shelter, food, etc to survive all this time. Eun Byul's money was only enough for approximately 10 days after she disappeared, then Eun Byul met that girl, afterwards the girl helped her. It makes sense if we think of it like that. If it's like that then Eun Byul knew everything that has happened in Eun Bi's former school from her.

 

That girl's motivation in giving out shelter and food for Eun Byul also matched. Eun Byul was Eun Bi's twin sister who stood up for her and was bullied in her stead until the point she committed suicide. That girl should have had a huge guilt about that especially considering she turned a blind eye when Eun Bi was bullied all this time.

 

What do you guys think?

Edited by riribl
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • love changed the title to [KBS2 Drama 2015] Who Are You: School 2015 (후아유: 학교 2015) Official Thread

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top