Red Velvet " ICE CREAM CAKE " or LOVELYZ " Hi~ "

[rayy]

~~ So no one made that Thread yet right?! GOTTA MAKE SURE OF THIS ISSUE FIRST .. 

 

No one can deny the fact LOVELYZ & Red Velvet are the most popular Rookie girlgroups .. and so there will be a kind of competition between both of 'em on MUSIC SHOWS since they've made Comeback in the same time .. technically .. 

 

But based on the song & MV & concept and so .. Which CB you think is the BEST ?! 

(( Please don't be biased )) 

 

LOVELYZ " Hi~ " 

 

 

RED VELVET " ICE CREAM CAKE "

 

 

 

Tbh, I liked both ..
We all have to admit both songs are such Jams ..
Based on the MV, ' ICC ' won for me, It's actually the most beautiful MV I've seen in my whole life *^*

All in all, Both are the Jackpot   

-- LOVELY VELVET FAN --

 

[Senbonzakura]

Hi was a really pretty video. Very dream like. However the song fell flat.

 

Ice cream cake had an awesome video concept and I dynamic song.

 

So I choose Ice Cream Cake.

 

 

But if you did Lovelyz first MV Goodnight like Yesterday vs Automatic I would Choose Lovelyz

[paopufruit]

Ice Cream Cake>>>

Hi was a little boring for me 

[Starlight]

I like both, but Ice Cream Cake suits my taste more~

[SNSTD]

ICC >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WOC>>>>>>>>>>>>>>HI~ 

[rayy]

Hi was a really pretty video. Very dream like. However the song fell flat.

 

Ice cream cake had an awesome video concept and I dynamic song.

 

So I choose Ice Cream Cake.

 

 

But if you did Lovelyz first MV Goodnight like Yesterday vs Automatic I would Choose Lovelyz

 

GOTTA APPROVE ><

[MermaidPrincess]

It's so tasty

Come and chase me daddy

 

[XStan]

Red Velvet wins.

[le youth]

ummm, the concepts are extremely different lol.  I like Lovelyz's concept better for this cb

 

In terms of what kind of songs I prefer, I'd have to go with Ice Cream Cake.  Thoughh, Hi~ is a nice bop to listen to as well.

 

MV is a tie. I like the tumblr-esque vibe of Hi~ and the colors and setting of Ice Cream Cake.

 

Overall, Ice Cream Cake was the better cb because I like the choreography and song a lot better. I'm looking forward to watching their lives~~

[palechibi]

Ice Cream Cake is such a great song in every way

[babystep]

song- and mv-wise I go with Red Velvet.

[Senbonzakura]

ummm, the concepts are extremely different lol.  I like Lovelyz's concept better for this cb

 

In terms of what kind of songs I prefer, I'd have to go with Ice Cream Cake.  Thoughh, Hi~ is a nice bop to listen to as well.

 

MV is a tie. I like the tumblr-esque vibe of Hi~ and the colors and setting of Ice Cream Cake.

 

Overall, Ice Cream Cake was the better cb because I like the choreography and song a lot better. I'm looking forward to watching their lives~~

I thought Ice Cream Cake was more tumblr like

[Moonbyun]

Ice Cream Cake. I'm a pretty big fan of both Lovelyz & Red Velvet, and I really liked "Hi~", but it lacks the originality of ICC. (i still love you kei bby)

[Park Joy]

God Velvet wins

[Sakura IS FEARLESS]

Ice cream.cake

[Soko]

ICC !!

[acclaim]

Ice cream cake slays me.

[۩ ♡ لا اله الا الله ♥ ۞]

I think comparing Hi with Automatic would be more fair 

[Cheesus]

Since I prefer more of an upbeat sing, with base and all.... ICC for me + the mv is really just so freaking perfect! the colour sand outfits and the freaking visuals. But when I'm feeling girlish/feminine , I'll listen to hi~

[rayy]

I think comparing Hi with Automatic would be more fair 

 

But AUTOMATIC has a R&B feel to it so No we can't compare R&B to songs as " Hi~ " u see ..

[DramaticTaeyeon"]

ICC is a certified bop. So ICC>>

[mikiangel]

ICC , the other song is not even close.

[aaaaaa]

Ice cream cake! ICC is jsut so catchy!!

[mochi]

ICC

Hi had pretty visuals, but it was a boring song

[Hazelwound]

Even RV's boring songs are better. Ice Cream Cake is their best song so far, so

ICC >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hi