SHINee's Orgel or f(x)'s Shadow?

[ezzie96]

So i recently came across a thread comparing My lady and Shadow, but i thought it was more fitting to compare Orgel and Shadow since they're both dreamy awesomeness and it'll make it'll probably make it more difficult to choose So what are your preferences? This is my first thread btw...pls no bashing xo

Orgel:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CC8nmv0Mc6k

Shadow:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxL-b09VBWw

 

[sarahh]

Orgel

[Cowabunga Dude]

The obsession international and domestic Kpop fans have with Shadow makes me think SM should've just taken the risk and made it their title track song instead of RPPP

[Hanah-]

Shadow is the only song on the album I dislike, so easily Orgel for me.

[humanoid]

Shadow

Orgel is boring after a few listens

[Meth Krystal]

Shadow easily

[Sarah-dk]

Orgel. easily.

[ezzie96]

The obsession international and domestic Kpop fans have with Shadow makes me think SM should've just taken the risk and made it their title track song instead of RPPP

i think they should've it would have been a refreshing change from the route that their title tracks have been taking recently

[#risejessica]

Shadow >

[youngwonstarz]

I love both, but i think i'll go for orgel

[Jongdae]

Orgel for me. Both are great though.

[banhbao]

I prefer Orgel, but both songs are pretty good. 

[Cowabunga Dude]

i think they should've it would have been a refreshing change from the route that their title tracks have been taking recently

SM should've prereleased it to see how it would've done on the charts for future "experiments" as far as title tracks go

[hyoyeon's lines in check]

They're both perfectly haunting but Orgel wins.

[Penis Intolerant]

Orgel, although I love Shadow as well.

[sadface]

Orgel easily. It's my favorite track in Shinee's album, while Shadow is not really to my liking ;A:

[Girls'Generation]

NOT VOTING

LOVE BOTH

 

but yeah they both have that same kinda musical effect going on...

 

The obsession international and domestic Kpop fans have with Shadow makes me think SM should've just taken the risk and made it their title track song instead of RPPP

kpop fans are tricky as fuck. everyone's dickriding shadow now but i bet if it was released as the title track, everyone would say it was too boring and weird 

[ChYkN]

This was hard, I love both songs buttttttttttttttttttttt I would have to pick Orgel. It's just so amazing. Shadow is amazing too though!!

 

Ugh I really wish SNSD's album had a song like this.

[jsa]

Orgel for me as well...

[Holke]

Orgel.

[Seulo]

Orgel

[snsdope]

The obsession international and domestic Kpop fans have with Shadow makes me think SM should've just taken the risk and made it their title track song instead of RPPP

 

I've been saying they should've made shadow the title ever since the RPPP teaser came out. I was disappointed in a way but still RPPP is fine enough. SM was just trying to be safe.

 

kpop fans are tricky as fuck. everyone's dickriding shadow now but i bet if it was released as the title track, everyone would say it was too boring and weird 

 

But being weird was their niche from the beginning. Being "experimental" was the whole reason for their existence from the jump. I think shadow would've been appreciated more in every regard.

[Girls'Generation]

I've been saying they should've made shadow the title ever since the RPPP teaser came out. I was disappointed in a way but still RPPP is fine enough. SM was just trying to be safe.

 

 

But being weird was their niche from the beginning. Being "experimental" was the whole reason for their existence from the jump. I think shadow would've been appreciated more in every regard.

 

meeehhh i don't think so lol f(X) is known for being eccentric and experimental yes but their songs are catchy and up-beat. shadow is not lol 

fans want things like electric shock and nu abo and hot summer (etc)

shadow is way too hipster. it only gets appreciated cause it's on the album

[ezzie96]

I've been saying they should've made shadow the title ever since the RPPP teaser came out. I was disappointed in a way but still RPPP is fine enough. SM was just trying to be safe.

 

 

But being weird was their niche from the beginning. Being "experimental" was the whole reason for their existence from the jump. I think shadow would've been appreciated more in every regard.

agreed..a pre-release of Shadow would've been great though, i think SM really needs to think about deviating from their performance based title tracks and do something a bit different. SHINee and f(x) would've been the perfect groups for them since they have that image of being experimental and different

[✽aya]

only songs i liked from shinee's MoM was evil and like a fire. didnt care for the rest. 

so, shadow for me~