Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing ~ Read Only Starting Dec. 20th ~ Shutdown Dec. 25th ×
OneHallyu

[KPKF] Comparisons of Suzy, Sulli, and Yoona's singing


JoJo29

Recommended Posts

Pann: [Question] Please rank Suzy, Sulli, and Yoona's singing


 

1.jpg

 2.jpg
 3.jpg


1. [+104, -35] Suzy >>>> Wall >>> Sulli, Yoona

2. [+99, -20] I don't know the worst one but Suzy is the best one

3. [+82, -77] It's such an embarrassment for Suzy ã…‹ã…‹ How dare you compare her to Yoona and Sulli? I'm already frustrated that she's being compared to their looks but now they're even comparing singing

4. [+34, -4] Suzy is the main vocalist in Miss A and she sung a several OSTs. She also did a duet with Bernard Park. Watch her singing Younha's song on Healing Camp. She also sung live on radio many times

5. [+33, -2] Suzy >>> Sulli > Yoona. Sulli and Yoona are at the same level but Sulli's voice is unique, at least

6. [+23, -0] I'm a non-fan. I think Suzy is the best one and Sulli is better than Yoona

7. [+22, -8] Ugh fuck ã…‹ã…‹ Just because Suzy is as pretty as Sulli and Yoona, it doesn't mean that her singing is as bad as them. Suzy wanted to become a singer because she liked singing. Suzy >> Wall >> Sulli because of her voice > Yoona

8. [+21, -18] You should compare Luna and Taeyeon to Suzy because they're also main vocalists. Taeyeon > Luna >>>>> Wall >>>> Suzy

9. [+19, -0] Suzy sang a few songs for Dream High and Sulli sings in f(x)'s songs sometimes. But Yoona raps in SNSD ã…‹ã…‹ "I'm surprised, I'm having a menboong~"

10. [+18, -4] If Miss A's main vocalist is Suzy, then just how terrible are the other members?
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3. [+82, -77] It's such an embarrassment for Suzy ã…‹ã…‹ How dare you compare her to Yoona and Sulli? I'm already frustrated that she's being compared to their looks but now they're even comparing singing

 

Suzy's korean fans are so arrogant. smh

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3. [+82, -77] It's such an embarrassment for Suzy ã…‹ã…‹ How dare you compare her to Yoona and Sulli? I'm already frustrated that she's being compared to their looks but now they're even comparing singing

 

Suzy's korean fans are so arrogant. smh

Look at the down votes tho

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8. [+21, -18] You should compare Luna and Taeyeon to Suzy because they're also main vocalists. Taeyeon > Luna >>>>> Wall >>>> Suzy

 

LOL no. Luna is way better than Taeyeon in my opinion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Aren't all of the Miss A members pretty much on the same level in singing?  To me when I see them perform I think

Singing: Min=Fei=Suzy >Jia (but she's only slightly behind them).  Min is the most consistent vocally among them live but I don't think their songs are vocally challenging so I don't actually know their true capabilities.

 

Dancing Min=Jia=Fei > Suzy (but she's only slightly behind here).  Fei might be a tiny bit better than the other 2 only because she has some diversity in her dance skills.  But it's hard to say if the others would do just as well since they haven't been given the chance to do so.

 

Acting.. Suzy's body of work far exceeds the others but skill wise from what I've seen they are on the same level.  Min feels the most natural acting but honestly she's only had tiny roles so it's hard to judge her. 

 

Variety - I'm more drawn to Min but honestly she's a bit embarassing sometimes and awkward lol.  Suzy gets by on her looks because 80% of her participation on the show revolves around how pretty she is.  She seems pretty easy going and down to earth but is pretty boring on variety outside smiling and laughing at whatever someone says. Fei seems pretty easy going but she's forgetable. I don't actually remember seeing Jia on a variety show.


if i rank them for their voices

 

sulli>suzy>yoona

 

if i rank them for singing abilitiy

 

suzy>sulli>yoona

What does that even mean? What's the diff?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Suzy's the best but both Yoona and especially Sulli have nice voices to listen too.

 

 

One thing that has always irked me about miss A as a group is that while they are all pretty decent singers there is not one "amazing" singer in the group i.e. hyorin, taeyeon, eunji, so it really hurts them in terms of what they can sing. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Suzy's voice is not weak at all. Of course it pales in comparison to Taeyeon, Hyorin, Eunji etc but IMO she could pass for lead vocal and has potential to become main with proper training. 

 

This for example is a solid performance:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top