Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

guava

Recommended Posts

OKAY this is my interpretation + from many Korean sites.

 

BOTH "Cha do hyun" and "Shin Se gi" are one of the same. Meaning, they're both the "original" personalities.

Shin Se Gi is the personality that EXPERIENCED the "abuse" and witnessed it. Hence, him saying that he was present for the pain and the horrible past.

 

However, Cha do hyun is the host that doesn't remember the past. The only thing keeping "SSG" and "CDH" from being "one" is the memory barrier. So CDH would be the "original" that never experienced abuse, while SSG is the "original" that DID experience it. (Am I clear here?)

 

Also :

 

-Yosub is a mirror image of the comatose state father's personality. The suicidal personality that was manifested from his depression and love for Min Seo Yeon.

-Yona is the mirror image of the idiot mother. (You can actually see this LOL)

-Nana is the seven year old ver. of Rijin.

-And of course, SSG is the original that experienced the abuse.

-Perry Park is speculated to be either the grandfather or Min Seo yeon's real lover. I would say the former because there's no way SSG could have met the lover of Min Seo yeon.

 

This is gonna be confusing because now, Ri jin IS Cha Do hyun, and Cha do hyun's actual name is actually Shin Se Gi. (Jesus)

 

And also, it's easy to switch genders and shit in Korea because birth certificate informations are hand written. As long the child is around the age of six, informations can be EASILY manipulated. (Not sure if it's still like that, but that's how it was)

Thanks for the explanations. I have been looking for details on how the personalities created. It is a bit confusing though. But i think we will know soon in the next episode. Ri jin must be having a hard time because she didn't know a thing before and now the memory came back.

 

 

Ohh. I just read your latest comment. And now it make sense. Shin Se Gi is really the original then.

 

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

Edited by Yaya_
Link to comment
Share on other sites

thanks alot for this.. i was confuse for a bit lol

 

I just hope the ending wont mess up ;_;

OKAY this is my interpretation + from many Korean sites.

 

BOTH "Cha do hyun" and "Shin Se gi" are one of the same. Meaning, they're both the "original" personalities.

Shin Se Gi is the personality that EXPERIENCED the "abuse" and witnessed it. Hence, him saying that he was present for the pain and the horrible past.

 

However, Cha do hyun is the host that doesn't remember the past. The only thing keeping "SSG" and "CDH" from being "one" is the memory barrier. So CDH would be the "original" that never experienced abuse, while SSG is the "original" that DID experience it. (Am I clear here?)

 

Also :

 

-Yosub is a mirror image of the comatose state father's personality. The suicidal personality that was manifested from his depression and love for Min Seo Yeon.

-Yona is the mirror image of the idiot mother. (You can actually see this LOL)

-Nana is the seven year old ver. of Rijin.

-And of course, SSG is the original that experienced the abuse.

-Perry Park is speculated to be either the grandfather or Min Seo yeon's real lover. I would say the former because there's no way SSG could have met the lover of Min Seo yeon.

 

This is gonna be confusing because now, Ri jin IS Cha Do hyun, and Cha do hyun's actual name is actually Shin Se Gi. (Jesus)

 

And also, it's easy to switch genders and shit in Korea because birth certificate informations are hand written. As long the child is around the age of six, informations can be EASILY manipulated. (Not sure if it's still like that, but that's how it was)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The theory mentioned above makes sense. The only differentiating factor between Dohyun and Segi is the memory of the abuse. Does this mean Segi is would Dohyun would have been if he had remembered all along? 

 

Hwang Jung Eum's character so far has been more of a rom-com character than anything. The next few episodes are probably going to change that once she regains her memories. I wonder how how she'll pull it off. 

Edited by sandεul!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well... I wasn't expecting that at all, wow.

The story is so interesting. 

Is that why Segi is so mad at Cha DoHyun? Because he was there first?

 

I do wonder if there'll be more than 20 episodes though, we still haven't seen Mr. X and nana.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So... let me get this right... cha do hyun is actually the nameless Mr.X, so in other words, there is no way, cha do hyun is actually the main personality, right? because it's impossible, since his whole existence is fake, i.e Shin Se Gi is the real one and somehow one of the personalities he created took over him while sharing some memories with him, right? I am really puzzled here, but there is no way Mr.X is the main personality, he might be the dominant one but he's definitely a fake one ... 

 

God! this drama is AWESOME!!!! I can't get enough of it, Ji sung is excellent in this, I love everything about this series except for the lead actress ... she overreacts all the times and doesn't seem like a doctor at all, it's pity they casted her for this role, because she's really ruining it for me and her face is crazy plastic ugly T___T too much surgery is so freaking obvious, her mouth is overly done >__< 

Ha Ji Won would have been perfect ...

ha_ji_won_01.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

God! this drama is AWESOME!!!! I can't get enough of it, Ji sung is excellent in this, I love everything about this series except for the lead actress ... she overreacts all the times and doesn't seem like a doctor at all, it's pity they casted her for this role, because she's really ruining it for me and her face is crazy plastic ugly T___T too much surgery is so freaking obvious, her mouth is overly done >__<

Ha Ji Won would have been perfect ...

ha_ji_won_01.jpg

it wil be perfect if it was Ha Ji Won. I agreed abt HJE.. idk if its script but i cant see her as a doctor most of the time, jisung save her lots

Link to comment
Share on other sites

THIS DRAMA MAKES ME CRAZY!!!!! Plot twist of plot twist!

 

I really can't predict the ending of this drama. Sure it's gonna be happy end but what's the solution? will Jisung ended up as Cha Do Hyun or Shin Segi? Or Both? Will his DID cured? What about other personalities? Will they vanished? Will they ended up as one? So its like a person with bipolar character? Just please dont make it cliffhanger!!!!!!!!!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It will be a bit weird for me if Ha Ji Won is rijin because i have known her with a serious character and rijin is not a serious one. Lol. But i am a bit curious to see if she can tho. But jisung's character, no one could do better than him. No one.

 

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just finished ep 16 and O.M.G. My prediction back then is most probably right.

Back then I predicted that CDH's real name (or core personality) may not be CDH but SSG instead, since SSG has the same surname with his mum (Shin Hwa Ran). And ORJ 100% isn't ORJ's real name as well. Now we all knows his real name isn't CDH. It's most probably SSG instead.

 

About CDH or SSG being the real personality, I think CDH is still the core personality. Since CDH doesn't remember his past he accepts his name as CDH, since it's most probably what people told him when he just woke up and didn't remember a thing. SSG alter, his name might be the real name but imo he's still an alter who has CDH's memory and resentful feelings to his family. He's a representation of it. Back then I contemplated if it's possible for SSG to be the core or not, but by now I dismissed that possibility already since from what I see SSG is acting like an alter instead of the core, like despite him wanting to take the main place several times, most of times he pushed and supported CDH to be stronger in his way. So yeah I think CDH is still the core personality.

 

 

So we established that no one other than Ji sung could really pull off the male lead in this drama... 

 

who do you think could have pulled off Oh Ri Jin? (Btw, the name Oh Ri Jin stems from the word Origin, meaning original -> She's the actual Cha Do Hyun)

 

Anyways, if Jun Ji hyun was a lot younger, I feel like she would have killed it because she's the Queen of romcom. 

But I remember how much I loved Go Ara in Reply 1994 and think she would have been a PERFECT Oh Ri Jin... 

 

 

I do appreciate Hwang, but she tends to overdo it sometimes LOL. 

 

I think HJE is perfect as ORJ especially since she doesn't hold back at all. When it comes to facial expressions, usually most other actresses are still pretty while acting out quirky personality but HJE is really into the role that she doesn't hold anything back including her expression lols Besides, I think ORJ is meant to be hyperbolic in the first place so that she won't be too bland and overshadowed by CDH's quirky alter personalities, and her hyperbolic expressions made the scenes much funnier as well. So I don't think of HJE's acting as ORJ as over the top.

 

Considering Jun Ji Hyun's too-cool-for-you and sassy image, I don't think she suits ORJ role since ORJ is someone who is warm-hearted, empathetic, and sensible. And for Go Ara, she might suit the role but I doubt she can pull off the quirkiness as well as HJE does. I watched Go Ara in You're All Surrounded, her role is also someone who's pretty quirky but I still can't imagine her pulling that aspect as well as HJE does.

Ha Ji Won, nah. She's too serious, elegant, and feminine for ORJ. The quirkiness would be reduced a lot if she were to act as ORJ.

 

These expressions

tumblr_njvqv2UHaS1u8yawfo1_400.gif

tumblr_njcgryQEji1sh8uxlo1_500.gif

-insert ORJ's crying expression when CDH made his comeback after being taken over by SSG-

 

Not anyone can or be willing to pull those expressions off on screen :lol:

 

All in all, imo HJE is perfect for ORJ and I can't imagine other actresses acting out this role as well as her.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i agree that hje's character is supposed to be hyperbolic

i also think a lot of it has to do with the directing

i saw a bts clip the other day where the director was telling hje to act with more excitement in a particular scene that they ended up redoing 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree there aren't a lot of actresses willing to give up their vanity and do these weird or exaggerated expressions the character (or the PD) demands. 

 

Someone on tumblr translated an excerp of her interview with Marie Claire

 

"I think that when you’re acting out a comedic scene, you shouldn’t be over acting. Even when a situation is funny, its funny because the acting is serious, but if I overdo it to be funny then it isn’t as funny. But in this drama I overdo it.

"(Laughs) I feel that my acting should be different from when I was in <High Kick Through the Roof>, but the director wants the type of acting from High Kick. However after watching the episodes that aired, I think I get it. Even if I act like how I was on High Kick, I’m no longer the same Hwang Jung Eum from that time. Instead I got to reopen parts that got locked away while acting throughout the past years.â€

 

 

cr. http://carameljazz.tumblr.com/post/111581261612/kill-me-softly-january-27-2015-maire-claire

 

I too believe CDH is the main personality, only now he doesn't know his name.

 

Sometimes  Song Ji Hyo and Hwang Jung Eum look a bit similar to me hahaha..

Edited by pelusa
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought I was predicting everything so far, but then bam there's something I didn't expect.

 

I have a question...if Rijin and CDH share the same mothers, does that not mean they are half siblings? I must've misinterpreted something, right? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Go ara would've been awesome for rijin. As much as i like the current actress playing the part, her crying really bothers me. She looks really weird LOL. And her face looks really plastic to me for some reason, but i do love her as rijin tho.

 

Contrary to you I really like her crying face, because her crying face is sooooo ORJ. It'd be weird to keep a pretty face when she cries considering how her character is imo. I like how she doesn't keep the prettiness and let it all out.

 

Imo her crying scene when CDH came back after being taken over by SSG is so cute, not only because of her expression but I also really like the vocalization (how she says her lines) at that time. Both of them are so ORJ :smile:

I can't find the gif nor a video cut of it sigh.

 

 

I thought I was predicting everything so far, but then bam there's something I didn't expect.

 

I have a question...if Rijin and CDH share the same mothers, does that not mean they are half siblings? I must've misinterpreted something, right? 

 

ORJ and CDH doesn't share the same mothers, ORJ's mum is Min Seo Yeon, while CDH's mum is Shin Hwa Ran. Pretty sure they have different fathers as well (CDH's father: Cha Joon Pyo, ORJ's father: might be someone MSY loves in America).

100% sure they won't be half siblings since they're romantically involved. The writer wouldn't dare to make it that way lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ORJ and CDH doesn't share the same mothers, ORJ's mum is Min Seo Yeon, while CDH's mum is Shin Hwa Ran. Pretty sure they have different fathers as well (CDH's father: Cha Joon Pyo, ORJ's father: might be someone MSY loves in America).

100% sure they won't be half siblings since they're romantically involved. The writer wouldn't dare to make it that way lol

 

Ohhh I see! Thanks :D

I got confused because CDH said that the photo is of his mother on the certificate or something. So they have different mothers and fathers but their mother and father married, but the father pretended to hate the mother.

And yeah, I guess so too, it would be a controversy...I hadn't thought of that, haha. When CDH was hesitant towards her, I misunderstood and thought it was because they are siblings. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ohhh I see! Thanks :D

I got confused because CDH said that the photo is of his mother on the certificate or something. So they have different mothers and fathers but their mother and father married, but the father pretended to hate the mother.

And yeah, I guess so too, it would be a controversy...I hadn't thought of that, haha. When CDH was hesitant towards her, I misunderstood and thought it was because they are siblings. 

 

Nah CDH was hesitant towards her is because his father abused ORJ instead of CDH whenever CDH made mistakes. That made him thinks he doesn't have right to be with her. Moreover he doesn't want Seungjin group to find out if ORJ is the missing child because ORJ's life can be in danger if that's the case, also he doesn't want to trigger ORJ's memory to come back because of him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nah CDH was hesitant towards her is because his father abused ORJ instead of CDH whenever CDH made mistakes. That made him thinks he doesn't have right to be with her. Moreover he doesn't want Seungjin group to find out if ORJ is the missing child because ORJ's life can be in danger if that's the case, also he doesn't want to trigger ORJ's memory to come back because of him.

Now it makes sense! 

CDH is so considerate. Poor him, he is never at rest. He is always tense because of his multiple personalities, and can't even love someone  :rlytearpls: since he was like that with chae yeon too. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • love changed the title to [MBC 2015] Kill Me, Heal Me Official Thread

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top