Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Someone post the full 29th GDA full nominee pls ?


huong_2503

Recommended Posts

In all honesty Mamamoo is the best rookie of the year..shame they're not even nominated just like how SPICA wasn't nominated when it was Exo vs BAP time

 

 

Side note: I'll be forever pressed that Ha:tfelt amazing album is not getting the recognition it deserves

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I already posted something in that thread that was about Super Junior and TVXQ not receiving nominations. But this is probably the more on topic place for what I want to say, so I'm posting it again.

 

I was under the delusionimpression that the Golden Disk criteria was sales only. I mean look at the old site: 

 

Not like other awards, winners are decided by the volume of album sales, so the Golden Disk Awards has received attentions in the industry. It also includes the digital music sales to the award as the growth of digital music music market. Since the award is based on the volume of album sales and the digital music sales, major and underground singers can have equal chances. For this reason, the Golden Disk Awards is able to precisely reflect the annual music industry and has been the award for the highest authority

 

Based on sales of Mr. Ambiguous, Mamamoo should have received a rookie award nomination. The song sold better than Happiness which is up for a digital bonsang (of all awards). And don't get me started on how Bernard Park snagged a nomination when he doesn't have a digital or physical album sales to speak of (but maybe I've missed those reciepts, if anyone has them...). 

 

Before the site went down I noticed that they only posted winning criteria, but I would be highly curious about the nomination criteria because it's a shame that they aren't getting acknowledged for being a rookie group that made an impact with their debut single. The least GDA can do is come up with some CYA criteria to justify their nominations. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I already posted something in that thread that was about Super Junior and TVXQ not receiving nominations. But this is probably the more on topic place for what I want to say, so I'm posting it again.

 

I was under the delusionimpression that the Golden Disk criteria was sales only. I mean look at the old site: 

 

 

Based on sales of Mr. Ambiguous, Mamamoo should have received a rookie award nomination. The song sold better than Happiness which is up for a digital bonsang (of all awards). And don't get me started on how Bernard Park snagged a nomination when he doesn't have a digital or physical album sales to speak of (but maybe I've missed those reciepts, if anyone has them...). 

 

Before the site went down I noticed that they only posted winning criteria, but I would be highly curious about the nomination criteria because it's a shame that they aren't getting acknowledged for being a rookie group that made an impact with their debut single. The least GDA can do is come up with some CYA criteria to justify their nominations. 

 

Yeah, Mamamoo deserves to be there actually and I also don't know why Happiness is in the bonsang (is it because of the impacts?). They really should post nomination criteria somewhere in the website later.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Mamamoo wants more recognition in Korea they have to do more stuff outside music shows. They have to get on variety and other things like that.

I don't think that's the issue. IMO, it's also not an issue of subjective measures like 'who is talented' or 'who has the songs I like'. Objectively they have the sales to be in the conversation. Which is backed up by their nominations in Melon and Seoul Music Awards. 

 

Though, I guess it doesn't matter what I think because if that list turns out to be legit, clearly Golden Disk's criteria was something other than (or in addition to) digital or physical sales.

 

*shrugs*

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can someone explain why no SJ? :derp:  I mean, they comeback after 2 years with one of the best selling album this year ..

The same for DBSK, on boy groups, it was EXO-SUJU-DBSK best sellers albums ánd repackage. but I guess suju is now suffering the curse of being OLD, that those shitty awards are doing to DBSK since 2011. -.-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top