Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

I am sorry A Pink but...


소유♥

Recommended Posts

I am so dissapointed with your new release. I am saying this not as a hater or am I jelaous about anything APink releated. I am a casual fan who only knows like 2 names mostly because of @Sasshi but I freakin loved every release since 'Hush', U You was like my GG song till Touch My Body and I am liking the new songBUT:
A few seconds into the MV and I am already thinking about how similar it is to their other songs.
First the light instrumental in the beginning followed by the chorus sounds so similar to My My.
Actually most A Pink title songs start with the chorus, MyMy, Hush Hush, U You, No No No, Luv. The only one that doesn't is Mr. Chu.
The front shoots in the beginning reminded me of a different song so much, I stopped watching the MV and searched for that instead.
The light pinkish colours, the lightning in most shoots are the same as in other videos of them.
Generally the MV is nothing new, not even one aspect, it looks like every APink video for me...There is nothing exiting to wait for when they release something new, maybe thats why I waited for the clear version of the song instead for the MV.
Also the dance, let's not talk about the dance.
All in one I will love the song to death but if they don't start to change even I will get bored with this, they need to stop making the same song over and over and over again and try something new. A new sound, maybe trying a different producer, doing a MV that doesn't look like a copy of their 6 others. Trying to make something NEW. And I am not speaking about them going dark or naughty or anything.
Discuss!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To be completely honest I felt like that after the first video of theirs I saw.. but if you like the song you shouldn't worry about possibly getting tired of it in the future. And couldn't you just post this in the Apink thread or the MV thread?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

honestly i feel like i'm the only one that doesn't like luv.

i still like apink but tbh the song was a boring, watered-down version of My My. also the song did not fit the MV at all, it should've been less upbeat.

i'd give this comeback a 4.5/10. sorry girls..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

this is actually a good criticism since most, if not all of your points are valid.. but let's not forget that S.Tiger produced the song that's why it sounds the same as their previous releases aside from MR.Chu which is from DS.

 

i think APink is building a distinct sound that ppl will remember and say "ahh.. this is an apink song" or something along those lines.. i could say that they kinda changed their concept just a little bit because they are not the "HAPPY-CUTE" or "CUTE-GIRLS-IN-LOVE" this time but "SAD-INNOCENT-GIRLS" 

 

they started to change even just a tiny bit and i hope they will start to explore more of this innocent concept of theirs..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To be completely honest I felt like that after the first video of theirs I saw.. but if you like the song you shouldn't worry about possibly getting tired of it in the future. And couldn't you just post this in the Apink thread or the MV thread?

Yeah, A Pink are one of the few groups where I love the music but still even I will get bored of it, and it was a criticism of their usual song structures and MVs and not only about the song Luv.

 

How would you rate it from MrMr to Slay

Slay >>>>>Luv >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>wall >>>>>>>>>>>>>Mr.Mr.(I like Mr.Mr.also but nowhere near as catchy as Luv)

 

Not a Star1 talking bout Apink music being the same when SISTAR's discography is a generic mess by Brave Bros

 

at least Apink copy their own songs and videos

 

what about SISTAR?

 

 

/thread

If you woudn't be such a mess you would realize that Sistar hasn't worked as a group with Brave Sound since 'Alone' more than 2 years ago.

 

Haters 

Why?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Unfortunately, I feel the same way somewhat. This is the 1st time that I was disappointed with an Apink title track tbh but I like the rest of the songs in the album though. I like Not an Angel. :)

 

Visually though, they all looked so pretty in the MV :ahmagah:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top