Mon3ko

So I meant to post this here but posted it in the shows thread... ooops lol. Thought I'd join in the fun. #8-12 are all super close. But I like them all. Swore Chaeyeon and Eunbi would be higher but eh.. is what it is. I guess I'm deep down a Yena stan.

EDIT: Ooops wrong thread... oh well still fits lol. Thought I'd join in the fun. #8-12 are all super close. But I like them all. Swore Chaeyeon and Eunbi would be higher but eh.. is what it is. I guess I'm a deep down a Yena stan.

Plus even compared with MixNine and Idol School, P48's ratings a lot better. & they stayed pretty consistent. On wiki they have the National Average for the whole season at 2.337. & the finale was 3.085 National & 3.299 Seoul. Now in comparison to the first two yeah its lower but it isn't bad by any means. The average for Season 2 was 2.968 & Season 1 was 3.01. Now both their season finale peaks are greater but still not bad for all the boycott talk. & I'm glad the group is trending decently. On NaverTV they still take up the top 5 spots.

Nekkoya (Piano Ver.) has got me all in the feels. I guess it hasn't even been a whole day but still lol. It's so pretty. & Nekkoya is still my favorite Produce Theme. I will say in retrospect, I'm really happy we got Chaewon. Her voice is so lovely.

I guess the finale song was Japanese first? Or maybe Itunes just used the Japanese name when it romanized it.

Oh cool! Thanks~ As I Dream is so pretty. Idk if I like the J or K version better. EDIT: & they're all up on Itunes now. Yeah Buddy!

I need these songs to pop up on Itunes!! NAO! Meh.. guess I'll be patient.

I'm here to stay, 6/12 of my initial picks isn't bad plus I like the lineup as a whole. (Still sad about Kaeun but nothing we can do about that now) But my main 4 made it!! SakuNakoEunChaeY! Woo Woo~~ Let's hope for a kick ass debut!! I can't wait for K-Style Idol makeovers.

I like how y’all both put this. As I really like Haeyoons voice y’all are right. Miyu needs this. Shine on lil Miyu. May they both make it in the top 12.

On the whole Miyu situation, if she drops that would suck but she just wants to prove herself.(I mean so did Yoonjin...) I really like Miyu & I have for some time but... ugh it’s just disheartening knowing that she will most likely suffer from her choices. She is definitely talented but so is Haeyoon & if I’m being honest she would have been the better choice. I’m still hoping Miyu pulls off a miracle & wows us all but I think the damage has been done.

Yeah,I was mesmerized by her cyborgness when she was younger. She definitely was eye catching , but she grew out of it. & Yujin could do the same with time. Tbh I wouldnt mind her in the group because she is an all rounder but Wonyoung is my preferred Starship girl.

Yujin reminds me of a cyborg.(kinda like early Mayuyu lol) a very cute cyborg though.(both Mayuyu & Yujin)

I know, but someone on here listed what it’d look like without the benefit and the ratio was opposite.

I mean if the few people in this thread who are saying the gp doesn’t care/only wota & otaku are voting, than shouldn’t the 1 pick top 12 look similar to what we have this round? (Minus the benefit votes of course.) so 7k-5j.(ratio without the benefit votes added)

Makes me wonder since the rankings were shown first if some stopped watching because of the J-heavy top 12. Either way we’ve had an elimination drop before. Hope the finale at least tops this season high. (2.8) But regardless on cloud nine about Sakuras #1. & I like the current top 12 but agree for the need for more vocal talent.(HaeYoon,Chowon, or Yuri)

So I’ve been a 46/48 group fan for some time but it’s my first time posting in here. I mostly follow Keyaki lately but I had a huge Nogi faze in the past. Had to look up this Zukki girl.(I’ve been off the Nogi bandwagon for a bit) But damn is she pretty. The 46 girls seem to have better overall visuals than their recent 48 counterparts. I will say as far as Keyaki is concerned I have high hopes for Hiragana Keyaki... they’re killing it. & 2nd gen are amazing for the most part. Kosaka Nao has snatched my Oshi spot from Berika & tbh I didn’t think that was possible. XD

So I’m still digging all the studio tracks... & my commute happens to be around 20 minutes, Which lets me listen to them all. Woo woo Happy fan!!! My own ranking of the songs. (I know it’s late but meh) 1. 1000% 2. See You Again 3. To Reach You 4. Rumor 5. Rollin’ Rollin’ 6. I Am

Rumor is that girl, the group performance is still near the top of Naver TV. (@#3) All the other group performances & a good chunk of solo cams are still trending. So that’s good right? All I ask from the National producers is SakuNakoChaeEunbi.

Visual ALL-KILL! MY KOKORO~

Now I’m not really in this debate, but what exactly can international J-idol fans gain by that? We have no say on any of the happenings of this process. We are all mere spectators on this.... & not trying to start an argument but every fandom has toxic fans. You see it on this site constantly. & international k-fans are just as malicious to each other(as seen in most twice, red velvet, & blackpink threads) so you honestly can’t expect this situation to be any different no? Not saying some of the hate might be coming from the j-side but you can’t just label it as all of it being from just them... JS. EDIT: I feel I've worded this funky, & I'm not even drunk. So I'll rephrase and just say the logic too this just doesn't make sense.

LOL OMG i feel so horrible but I edited it!!! Thank you. & she was in my two pick until NAKOGATE. (I still love her but I've just lost hope....)

Okay so I’m slightly bored watching broduce But since it’s been like 24 hours since the solo cams came out let’s make a list! Naver Likes/Views: 1. Chaeyeon 15479 / 173516 2. Eunbi 8208 / 136224 3. Sakura 7978 / 294609 4. Miru 6288 / 129058 5. Nako 5938 / 75386 6. Sian 5316 / 142887 7. Miu 4979 / 99545 8. Yuri 4756 / 53738 9. Chaewon 4705 / 46050 10. Yena 4532 / 50552 11. Wonyoung 4303 / 74182 12. Miho 4255 / 68413 13. Hitomi 4224 / 45013 14. Sihyun 4124 / 55437 15. Miyu 3843 / 60456 16. Gaeun 3648 / 71547 17. Sae 3556 / 34863 18. Juri 3538 / 33447 19. Minju 3463 / 79119 20. Yujin 3415 / 52956 21. Chowon 3228 / 39621 22. Doah 2633 / 101790 23. Moe 2574 / 29372 24. Nayoung 2557 / 26036 25. Hyewon 2461 / 31672 26. Haeyoon 2438 / 21337 27. Yunjin 2386 / 103225 28. Yiren 1905 / 68819 29. Gyuri 1610 / 20747 30. Goeun 1215 / 12497 If I messed up on a name, oops I’m multitasking here! But poor Goeun... I know someone’s gotta be the bottom but she deserves better. But go Chaeyeon!! AH I left out Yoonjin... FIXED! Someone else can do Youtube... I'm spent! XD

You know you can quote multiple people in one post instead of constantly multi-posting? Not trying to sound naggy but its just a pet peeve I'm sorry!! lol & I swore the Wuppsle term was originally K-Nets/P48 fans and we kinda just ran with it....

I sincerely hope everyone here can at least be civil and appreciate the girls for the effort they put in. They're all trying and doing a great job imo. We like who we like! But dang man all this waiting, I need this group to debut so I can just STAN ALREADY! Anyways guess I'm gonna watch Season 2 in the mean time.

& she’s surpassed Sakura in likes. Get it Chaeyeon!! I wonder if this has anything to do with that article about supporting her.(Saw it in the netizen sub forum) But if she does go viral cause of this it’d be good for the k-side. Last Korean trainee that got oomph on Naver was Gauen(side to side) after all the hate & what Wonyoung with very very before that?