ethereal

fun and neutral with a total bop

Very happy for Somi. Baby girl is doing good on the poll.

The fighting will never stop, unfortunately. That's fandom culture for you.

I'd be happy with this lineup if Chaeyoung replaced Dahyun and Jihyo. was added. No matter how much I look at it, this group needs to be 8 or 9 members to be as well rounded as it needs to be.

Hun, did you for get the whole momo thing, or...????

There is no reason to keep bringing up the cheating because of the fact that everyone is doing it. Why harp on something that isn't going to change no matter how much you complain about it? One thing about people here is that they keep bringing up the same thing over and over again "____ is too young", "I don't want ____ in Twice because ___". I feel like the same people are always saying the same things and I would hate to be that person with the cheating thing. It has nothing to do with the fact that Somi has risen. It has to do with the fact that the cheating won't stop and as long as I myself am not doing it, I have nothing to feel guilty about because I'm living according to my standards and values.

I don't get why people keep coming for stans of a particular member. Like, me personally, I like most of the girls a lot and will support Twice no matter what, but Somi is my bias. she the one I like the most and as her #1 fangirl on this forum, I feel the need to promote her and defend her and show my support in any thread where it is plausible to make mindless stan comments. Tzuyu has fans like this here, Mina has fans like this here, Momo had/has fans like this here. It isn't fair to single out one group of stans imo, because everything you said applies to a lot of other people, too. Of course everyone thinks their bias is the best, that's why we like them, because we see something in them that others don't necessarily.

I know this post is directed at me and I don't really see how I brought down the older girls..? I honest to god think almost all of the girls have a similar amount of potential and talent, especially in the vocal department.

you don't have to be fucking rude about it, though. really off-putting to see people trashing kids who are working just as hard and are just as talented as most of the older girls, tbh. Somi already has a voice a little more stable than Tzuyu's and she's two years younger. Imagine how great she'll be when she herself is 16. I've said this before, but Somi in particular, I want to see her grow into a talented young idol with Twice. I don't just want to wait for the final product. I want to see her progress, I want to be able to support her as a member and talk about all of her progress by next year. And aren't music show filmings done like at 9-10 am? I saw the times that idols under 16 aren't allowed to work (only without parent consent, which I'm sure the parents have given if the girls can practice late at night and film the show when they are in minor) and it doesn't seem to conflict with most music shows, from what i've seen. The age argument is so invalid, it legitimately is beginning to piss me off every time I see people bring it up. These girls are so much more than their ages, like, get over it. Somi is most likely going to be a member of Twice, tbh.

I really can't condone cheating. It's really gross to me and I think I might have to leave this thread for a bit. Peace out. how can anyone cheating live with the fact that their bias is only moving up in ranks because of their cheating and not because of popularity.......

but sana is in 6th

Future hip hop sub-unit pls

Oh, fuck, the top 7 girls as Twice would be a dream come true. Though I still want Jiwon and Jihyo...

You could say the same about Somi, Mina, and Sana. What makes Tzuyu any better than them? Honestly, someone please tell me what she's done to be better than them. I don't hate her, I don't hate any of the girls, I'm just genuinely curious why her fans are so cut-throat about her when I haven't really seen her shine that much personally.

I saw some people before saying it would still be a vs thing but then rather than finding a final looser all the girls that lost would be minor and one of them would be eliminated. But still, a team with the three most popular members up against everyone else??? Who do you think is going to be safe strong vocalists: Jiwon, Jihyo, Minyoung vocal to improve: Somi, Mina, Tzuyu, natty, Chaeryeong (sana?) stable vocals: Nayeon, Jungyeon, (sana?) decide for yourself who you think deserves to stay.

Dude, he freaking put Tzuyu, Nayeon, and Jungyeon in a group together. Up against Somi, Natty, and Mina. I repeat, UP AGAINST SOMI, NATTY, AND MINA. It's clear who is going to win and it's clear what he is trying to do here.

I think the main point of this show is to a) gain public interest and b) gauge the public's response. JYP clearly values the public's opinion and is using it to rework his judgments of some of the girls. Rather than going in with a blank slate I think he went in with an idea that was open for change based on the new deciding factor, the public. That's why he keeps doing these freaking group challenges with live audience votes. He's slowly weeding out the girls who aren't popular. That's what I think.

Thank you for saying this.

that's you're opinion, not a fact, honey. It would also mean one of the more popular members would be sacrificed and I don't see that sitting well with a lot of this group's supporters. That's all i'm going to say.

It's not like the milk poll doesn't matter at all, though...js

I just looked at the poll, and no, there is still a significant gap between Natty and Minyoung and I don't think Minyoung will be passing Natty any time soon. And how is it a double standad? I never said the poll wouldn't count for Jihyo. Jihyo is literally right on Somi's tail right now and could overcome her and Chaeyoung at any moment. So it would count positively unlik e for MInyoung where her position is not helping her.

If people really want ot4 so badly, why aren't Minyoung and Jihyo higher on the milk app? I honestly feel like ot4 is a delusion that only international fans are grasping at. Clearly the Korean fanbase doesn't give a shit about all the japan line and ot4 crap. I -fans love to make stuff like this up. And yeah, anyone could argue that the milk poll is simply a glorified visual ranking all they want, but out of the girls in the minor section of the poll, i'd only fight for Somi, Jihyo, and Jiwon. No he wouldn't have to get rid of Jihyo. Obviously the milk poll is just a reference and not a basis for any of JYP's decisions except maybe for the girls in the top 3 or 4, but Minyoung being dead last since basically the second week is something he can't and shouldn't ignore.

He could just get rid of Minyoung like the majority of the Korean public clearly wants.

But so what if they didn't see them? Even if the girls aren't in the show anymore, it's not like they're no longer trainees, so just because they weren't seen at a certain time doesn't really say anything, really.....I'm holding on to hope for Jiwon because I really need her vocals in this group. Really,