Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Tiskitosk

Member

Posts posted by Tiskitosk

  1.  

     

    No worries, I usually don't get into convos/discussions much here (unless its to welcome newbies cause I feel a sense responsibility laugh.png ) but when I do, its because I find it interesting. And I enjoyed this one despite us having different views. ^-^

     

    True. I only started to see the traits I listed as prominent when she was already in Slytherin. 

     

     

     

    Different views is what makes an interesting discussion ^^

     

     

     

    Even more causal Taeng, I'm living ahmagahplz.png She's had this whole theme going on in her latest posts, and suddenly that random Persona pic lol

    • Like 1
  2.  

     

     

    I guess it depends on the questions because mine were mostly situational. That's were I based my sorted based on one's choices statement from. The only random question I got was the last one, left or right. Which I think is based on your impulse decision like how the questions were in the patronus quiz. 

     

    I also think the psychology behind the answers is what determined the result. 

     

     

     

    I like Luna, that's probably why. ^-^

    That's where we differ, because I separate personality test from the sorting quiz.

    I believe personality or character is what defines you as a person. It takes time to develop and change. Attitude on the other hand is how you handle or approach certain things. A choice that you make given the situation or environment you are in.

     

    The Weasly twins, despite being naturally ambitious, cunning and most importantly, pure blooded, were sorted into Gryffindor instead of Slytherin. 

     

    Its totally cool if you think she would fit more in Hufflepuff, I'm not trying to convince you otherwise, she does have some of their traits. We have different views and that's what makes an interesting discussion.

    And no it wasn't me. laugh.png

     

     

     

    To anyone wondering where I based the traits I posted in previous page.

     

    Traits I think she have:

     

     

    Misunderstood / Complex

    "I was hurt a lot too. ‘Ah, this is how I’m being perceived. That’s not my intention. I can be viewed like this.’ I think I’ve felt a lot of these types of feelings." 

    "I’ve developed a self defensive side due to being concerned about people’s misunderstandings. With the same words, many people have their own interpretations."

    "Truthfully, I’m not sure if I know myself very well. It’s too difficult to describe myself with one word."

     

    I believe you can still be true to yourself without being consistent in your approach, you can have multiple layers without the surface being fake or 'less you'.

     

    Loyal / Leadership

    "The reason I like Taeyeon is because she's not fake. She treats people with honesty. She knows how to take care of her friends." -Heechul

    "Taeyeon is the type to take care of you without you knowing. She doesn't say, 'I will do this for you,' to your face, but she takes care of you behind your back." -Seohyun 

     

    They got strong sense of taking care of their own, prioritizing it over everyone else even themselves. Loyal to a select few, but are very protective of them.

     

    Reserved

    "If you look at just my personality, I like to keep things to myself and hide away, rather than showing everything."

    “I’m careful about expressing my emotions. I’m not the type to often share my thoughts. I leave the past where it ends, and I don’t write in a diary either.â€

     

    They try not to wear their true emotions on their sleeves. They don't like to show weakness or anything that might be considered as such. Instead they bottle it up, using it in other ways, some of which may be artistic. 

     

    Stubborn / Flexible

    "I would like to sing properly, at least once. I haven’t yet done it to the point where I’ve reached my limit. Since I’m out publicly as a singer, I’d like to do it properly at least once and then attempt other things." 

    "If you say idol, you could think of them wanting to appeal in a visual, external way. In every genre, it would be nice to show myself, but I still think the focus is music. I’m always asked about various things like fashion, style or interests but I only really want to talk about music."

     

    Be stubborn on your goals but flexible on your methods.

     

    Resilient

    2008 & 2014

     

    Outspoken

    Called out staff for poor sound system.

    Called out SM few times for their messistakes. 

    Stood up for herself numerous times. 

     

    Charming / Prowess

    Kim Taeyeon.

     

     

     

    Traits I think she values/prominent:

     

     

    Perfectionist / Passionate

    "We did a ballad for Taeyeon's first EP, it's called Gemini. We went down to the studio where she was recording it with an engineer. She played it to us and we were like 'That sounds amazing! You killed it!' She doesn't speak that much English and the engineer was like 'Yeah she's going to scrap this, and record it all again. She's just laying it down roughly because she's still learning it.' We were like 'Really? You're going to recut it all?' It sounded banging to us. That was quite cool to see how much of a perfectionist she is."

    "When I sing a new song, I take it as a challenge and I am ready to work on it and keep working until I am completely satisfied."

     

    LDN Noise mentioned Taeyeon as one of the memorable studio recording experiences. They said Taeyeon is an unbelievable singer who raise a song to another level. 

    And that time she wanted to sing Time Lapse again, cause she felt like it wasn't good enough.

     

    Ambitious / Determined / Driven

    "I would love to be able to plan a world tour."

    "It’s a similar feeling as wanting to study hard and do well in school to receive compliments from your parents. I want to receive a good grade and show everyone."

     

    She might want to conquer the universe or maybe just wanted to do something just because others say she can't. Ambition is having strong desire to do or achieve something. Following one's dreams with a clear goal. Ambitious and determined, there's a huge possibility that she will succeed because she will stick to it until the very end. She works hard to achieve her goals.

     

    Like what she is doing right now.

    "I want to enjoy the city streets and works of art! The UK and Greece."

     

    Adaptable / Clever / Resourceful

    "I do think that there needs to come a time when I can’t be afraid anymore. If situation changes, a person needs to change to adapt. I will try hard so I won’t be afraid and I will watch over things that need my attention"

     

    Prepared

    "I didn’t think rap was right for my first album and I think I still need more time for rap. We’ll put rap on hold for now."

    "I’m only saying that right now, the timing is not right for me to proactively write lyrics, but going forward, who knows if there will be a day when something will happen or I’ll be inspired to write a lot."

     

    It took her 8 years before going solo. Either she did prioritize SNSD more (^loyal/leadership) or she was definitely well prepared when the time came, or both.

    Not running into a battle out of an act of adrenaline and bravery. They go in there with a strong idea of what they want to achieve, and how they're going to get there.

     

    And finally that "certain disregard for the rules". laugh.png

    Little mischievous yes, but not necessary rule-breaker, she's too good for that, more like bending the rules.

     

    Mainly because they don't believe there's only one “right†set way of doing things. Even when they do end up breaking every rules/limitations set by others but they will never break their own rules/standard they set for themselves. 

     

     

     

    Taeyeon fits right in, or maybe she just really likes the official colors green and silver with the unofficial one, black (fascination for skulls, jack, etc.) laugh.png

     

    I'm in no way painting her negatively (since Slytherin is the only house defined by what others consider as negative traits) This is just where I based my comment that she fits just fine in the house, which is not necessarily a bad thing. 

     

    Since I posted this long essay (which will be the last cause OT sorry >.<) I will end this with few pics of Taeng looking good in dark hair and green scarf. 

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    I honestly mostly disregard that whole quiz when discussing the houses, because I don't think it's good. As I said previously, your answers don't mean much when you don't get the chance to explain your reasoning behind them. I also feel like the quiz paints Slytherins in a very bad light. The focus is mostly on the power-hungry, egocentric side of Slytherins and not on any of their other traits which you have described very well in your previous post.

     

    I like Luna too ^^

     

    About the personality test thing, I just thought it was interesting because it might tell us a little more about her. But of course, we don't know how accurate it really is. But from the way she talked about it and since she decided to share her result, I assumed she must have found the personality description at least somewhat accurate. And a lot of the traits listed for the ISFJ personality type just happen to match very well with Hufflepuffs: Selfless, kind, sensitive, loyal, empathetic, considerate, responsible, trustworthy, practical, traditional, dislikes conflict

     

    I'm not trying to convince you of anything either, I just find the conversation really interesting. And it's fun to talk to someone who shares both my love for Taeyeon and my passion for Harry Potter laugh.png

     

    I know you said this was your last post on the topic, but I just have to comment on some of your points, sorry for dragging this further

     

    I agree with almost everything you posted. I do think she has/values all the traits you mentioned, but I don't see all of them as strictly Slytherin traits. At least loyal/leadership, passionate and reserved/don't show emotions are traits that fit into both Hufflepuff and Slytherin, but in slightly different ways. I suppose I see them as more Huffleupuff than you do, and that's why we differ

     

    Traits I think she has/values that could be seen as typically Hufflepuff

     

    Loyal

    Dedicated

    Hard working

    Tolerant

    Patient 

    Humble

    Honest

     

    I think the main reason why I find it hard to picture Taeyeon as a Slytherin is because I've always seen Slytherins as people who value success more than anything else, who like to be in control and who are very self confident and don't care much about what other people think of them. These are traits I don't necessarily see in Taeyeon, although I might be wrong of course. Again, not saying these are negative traits, or that they are the only traits which define a Slytherin, but I do think they are an important part of the house. There are also some Slytherin traits I definitely see in her tho, but I'm not going to go over them again because you described them so well in your post 

     

     

    What I have realized form this conversation is that it is impossible to place someone based on personality and character when you only have four boxes to put them in. She kinda fits into both houses depending on how you look at it

     

     

  3.  

     

     

    Random?

     

    It wasn't for me.

    And that was my point, the quiz didn't know us personally, like our characteristics and traits. We got sorted based on the choices we made in a situation we were put in.

     

     

     

    Exactly!  

     

    And no that wasn't directed to anyone in particular, I meant it in general. ^-^

     

    I also don't know Taeng personally but just like how the sorting hat did consider Hermione in Ravenclaw (the house everyone seems to expect she'll be in) but more than books and cleverness, she clearly felt courage was of greater value than the accumulation of knowledge. She herself preferred Gryffindor. Same as how Luna is in Ravenclaw (instead of Hufflepuff based on how kind and compassionate she is) because unlike Hermione who is limited by the books, she has the ability to think outside the box, which she visibly excelled at. She embraces and is proud of that ability of hers. 

     

    I myself don't know how Taeng ended up in Slytherin, whether she took the quiz or not, its clear, she made her choice and she seems happy being one. laugh.png 

     

     

     

    I don't think whether I prefer dusk or dawn, forest or river or what goblet I would like to drink from says anything about who I am as a person. Your answers alone don't really say anything about you, but the reasoning behind your answers would tell a lot, but the quiz don't show that, unfortunately.

     

     

    You make some really good points. I like how you described Luna especially. Still, no matter how I look at it I just don't really see the Slytherin traits as the most prominent in Taeyeon even tho she definitely has some of them. Especially after reading the results of that personality test she took. But again, what I think isn't really important. 

     

    You're right about that. She has made her choice and is happy about it, I'm not going to take that away from her. And even tho I personally don't see Slytherin in her as much as I see some of the other houses, I'm not surprised she picked that house. As you have mentioned previously (at least I think it was you?) Taeyeon seems to have a fascination for things that are sort of bad ass and a little mischievous laugh.png

     

     

    On another note, Taeyeon seems so happy in London!! It looks like she's enjoying herself and is having a really good time, and that makes me extremely happy too. She has worked so hard this year, so this break is definitely well deserved. Even if she is filming something, which I wouldn't complain about since I'm always thirsty for more Taeyeon material, it does seem like she's having a lot of free time to do the things she wants as well 

  4.  

    You don't need to, those are just what I noticed. And not all those qualities I mentioned are necessarily mean or evil, I'm not painting her that way. 

     

     

     

    Have you taken the official quiz? Maybe it will put you in Hufflepuff.

     

     

     

    I find it interesting too, like how we seem to take our Hogwarts House so seriously. laugh.png

     

     

     

     

     

    I still believe you are sorted not by the traits you already have but by the ones you value the most.

     

    Because if that was the case, Hermione would've been in Ravenclaw, Luna a Hufflepuff, Cedric a Gryffindor and the Weasly twins as Slytherin. It's the same reason why you have an entire family of Weaslys in Gryffindor and entire family of Malfoys in Slytherin because they were raised to value certain traits. Honor and bravery for Weasly kids and ambition and loyalty for Draco.

     

    The sorting quiz also didn't know us personally, but we got sorted based on our choices and answers.

     

     

    To those taegangs out there that are sorted into Slytherin, there are so much more to being a Slytherin than what people seem to believe. It means you are enduring and strong. The negative stereotypes and traits have hardly anything to do with your sorting, you are not a bad person. Positive characteristics are what counts. For those of you part of this house be proud because it means you are a strong person and probably one of the best part is you have Kim Taeyeon as fellow Slytherin! 

     

    7Rq43Gs.gif

     

    Though, to those who don't take it seriously but got sorted into Slytherin, I think the sorting quiz considered one's love for water, so don't feel bad if that was the reason why you're sorted into the house compared to your other answers. laugh.png

     

     

    Taeyeon never showed us her results but if the kid wants to be a Slytherin, then she can be anything she wants. 

     

    2BLOxmZ.gif

     

     

    The official quiz did put me in Hufflepuff, so I was happy, but the questions in that quiz are pretty random. Most of them don't have anything to do with personality really, and that's what i find interesting to discuss.

     

     

    Harry Potter and Hogwarts houses are important, so it should be taken seriously! 

     

    And btw, it's not that I think Slytherin is a bad house full of bad people, not at all. My point is that based on Taeyeon's personality I never felt like Slytherin is the house where she fits the most. And I know it's kinda stupid to think that way because I don't know her personally, but judging from what we see and also from that personality test she took Slytherin seems like a weird fit imo. But maybe she actually fits there perfectly, and I have misjudged her completely, or maybe Slytherin was just her result on the quiz or maybe she just thinks the house is cool or all of the above, what do I know. 

  5.  

    Traits I think she have + ones values:

    Determined

    Misunderstood

    Ambitious

    Leadership

    Resourceful

    Stubborn

    Prepared

    Reserved

    Clever

    Perfectionist

    Bold

    Outspoken

    Charming

    Prowess

    Resilient

    Driven

    Passionate

    Loyal

    And she's destined for greatness.

     

     

    Those are the only ones I can think of right now, there's probably more. 

     

    The other houses are cool too and she has some of their known traits, but like you said, the sorting hat itself takes one's wishes into account when sorting.

     

    Hence, 

    cr38x5F.jpg

     

    Its not the color either, because then she would've preferred to be a Ravenclaw. She's a potterhead, so I think there is something in Slytherin that she relates and identify the most. 

     

    ZCxK28F.jpg

     

    Others tend to overlook the good qualities of a Slytherin because of the reputation, but we do have them. laugh.png

     

    I'm not sure if I agree with all of those actually 

     

    But then again, I don't know Taeyeon and she knows herself best, obviously. I just find it really interesting to discuss. And the Hogwarts houses are really complex (Slytherin is possibly the most complex one) and Taeyeon is also a complex person, so she's difficult to place imo. I'm just really happy Taeyeon is as passionate about Harry Potter as I am!

     

    And you're right about Slytherins often being misunderstood, and that people tend to overlook their good qualities. After all Severus Snape, one of the most interesting characters in the Harry Potter universe, was a Slytherin! 

     

    I personally want to be a Hufflepuff, but the more I think about it the more i realize that I might not actually fit there, sigh...

  6. I actually think Taeng would fit right into Slytherin. laugh.pngI bet she even used floo powder to travel to London. za5g21G.png

    Because I believe you aren't sorted by what traits you have but by what traits you value the most. 

     

     

     

    What Slytherin traits do you feel like Taeyeon values? I've always felt like she fits in Hufflepuff, because some of the main characteristics of a Hufflepuff is being hard working and dedicated. And we all know Taeyeon works really hard because she is passionate about music and not because she's achievement oriented, which is one of the Slytherin traits

     

    On the other hand, the sorting hat takes your own wishes into account when sorting, so maybe it would place her in Slytherin after all laugh.png

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top