RATY

She still lacks a solo performance to showcase all of her potential ,Based on her materials showing to us now, I don't think she is AA-P Because compared to Baek Yerin's low AA-P, I think Yerin had a better time than Lily when she belting.

What is Nayul 12DAL ranking? I saw that she could support D5, I thought someone might have talked about her here

He has support for F4 or even sometimes at F#4 ,Yes I saw that post but I didn't press into it to hear how he did with it, personally I think his F4 lacks the basis for development from what I linked to the video, he's stuck and that support is inappropriate, I don't know who is better between him and JB Got7 but they sound similar in their ways. (I'm a beginner, I'm studying in my country's university about singing, I think my ear has not developed so I might be wrong.)

What do you think of this performance by Seungmin Stray kids? @4.44 @4.48 F#4 @5.02 F4 I don't like it, In the finally he dropped his support. @5.09 F4 This one sounds better @5.16 F4 Again, he dropped the support

I don't know how accurate this video, There are some notes in here that I don't agree with labeling Resonance (I feel it's not expanded enough but I might be wrong)

Haechan and Taeil have agility better than the other Main vocal in Nct. @3.02 Haechan did a great job here.

They can show relaxing moments that are lower than A4. Often sings by using air instead of proper support, I personally haven't heard any proper support from them.

In this video, overall I like the F4-A4 Taeil's is more than Doyoung but F#4 Doyoung's pre-debut is really good, Taeil's @5.23 Bb4 I think there's some support but I think it sounds pushing and tense to me, l think it needs to be developed more.

Yes, Taeyeon was able to show her support for F#3 but personally I wouldn't call it consistent

I go back and read old posts, I see someone saying Taeyang of BigBang that he is that baritone, is it true?

He singing in B3-F#4,he didn't put in much effort,it does not open but gave a fuller voice and strong than the other main vocalist in Nct.

I like Baekhyun's first G4.

D.O. belt A4

@ZRH23 If there was a ranking, who would you choose in front , Between Taeil and Doyoung ? I've seen many people say that they can both be interchangeable. Taeil seems to be more advanced in D3-G4/G#4. Although he was mostly supported by tight and whiny,He lacks consistent performance in A4 right now Doyoung also lacked the development of Chest voice and sometimes when he used the belt,The sound was projected back into his throat. but he did better than Taeil when using the phrase G4-A4 and the development of the Bb4 area

I think Jung seunghwan and seungkwan is more like AA-P than AA or am I missing something?

Kihyun Monsta X ranking? He looks like Average with F4/F#4, but I don't know how well he's doing.

?

I guess most singers' regression is due to vocal cord problems and has resulted in them having a bad habit in their singing? (I hope to have Yuju on the next list).

Most of the Eb5s in the clip seem to be supported but light I want to see the recording of In My Dream

Sungjae's Lower Bb2/B2 is impressive for Tenor . Jaehyun below D3 is not the best compared to other Tenor. Sungjae has sense of support that's strong and still has the fuller. Jaehyun coordination is soft E4-F#4 lack fullness ,He still need a lot more chest voice

Sungjae is not a baritone, so what's his rank? @2.51 E4 @2.45 E4 @2.48 G4 @2.51 G#4 @3.49 F4 @4.29F4 @0.13,@0.18 F#4 @0.3 F#4

Thanks for the explanation, it's really interesting and it's really a shame I missed discussions about her vocal type, I'm really shocked coz she's always called Mezzo-Soprano, even the university I'm studying is using her as an example.

I'm shocked that Beyonce' is Soprano Her support for C3 is amazing, Even though it's rare!

She looks more like Low Average, she has a few moments that are not shallow @1.02