-
Posts
271 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Won
52,875 [ Donate ]
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Articles
Posts posted by Xinon
-
-
ugh here you are constantly misreading every post i type. I said the member AFTER her. Stop misquoting everything i say and twisting every point i make.
and when i said ugly vocal riffs, its exactly what indian member was doing at 0:43 before that other member came in with the flat note.
Bolding certain parts because i know you can't read. Reading is obviously difficult for you.
so everyone needs a major in music in order to criticize music?
Anyone with ears can judge music, just like anyone with eyes can judge art. Your comment is beyond ignorant and elitist.
i'm really enjoying this desperate attempt from you to invalidate any negative criticism about this group. Why so oversensitive? People aren't allowed to think this group is subpar? Everyone must only say nice things about any group that has SEA members in it?
Its clear you have the Inability to handle criticism. People who are like that never grow. They stay at the bottom.
With that kind of ears of yours is difinetly telling that ur no good in music, that's not even music criticism
@:43 the member who sung in that time stamp is Priyanka and the member after here her is Vanya her line is flat? LMAO..
-
-
I have basic knowledge in vocals and I don't heard Priyanka going flat in that line and those numerous ugly riffs you said is OK for me and even for the reactioners who is a vocal teacher they said its nice to heard a traditional singing style.omg you still don't even read the point correctly lol
this is best excuse you could come up with?

Its another clear sign of amateur handling/quality within the group. No professional company would let something like that slip into a DEBUT TRACK. They would not give them a song that they aren't capable of singing (especially if it still shows up on the studio recording). And if it does show up, why not fix it at least?
People so desperately want to see an foreign girl in a group like this that they ignore the sloppyness of the entire thing (for example the numerous ugly vocal riffs throughout the entire song).
We should be valuing quality first. Not what country they came from.
Ugly vocal riffs and flats are you major in music? Lmao
-
[quote name="Walmart Goddess
-
Bullsh*t is on drugs now. Debut my girls now before you talking sh*ts that we know will flop!
-
which small guy?
In the vlive video
-
Midam looks so nervous and stiff I hope he can make it, he deserves all the good things in this world ,
Who's the small guy with black hair
-
I hope we have more foreign trainees just to make it more global.
-
Can someone tell me who's that guy who looks like Wannaone Bad Jinyounb with a long hair?
-
I'm talking about the people who stan this mess. DUH! They are desperate to have their nationality be seen/validated by others that they are willing to ignore clear red flags coming from this messy project. Just like the people who were stanning Alex.
and if you don't think this group totally isn't trying to appeal to the whole current k-idol fan culture, then you're a fool.
and if you still can't read or comprehend any of the points i'm making, then i can't help you. You're a lost cause.
the girl group song sounds like a badly mixed/performed/written Meghan Trainor song. Look at 0:43 to see what i was talking about when i say messy vocal delivery which was followed by another member doing a flat note that the producers didn't even bother to fix lol. And i'm not going to delude myself into liking it just because there is a thai member in the group,
as for the boy group. I don't even i have to explain how bad that entire video was lol.
So yeah, these are pretty much EXP edition-like groups that got way less hate because they weren't white.
The whole kpop groups want to validate something.
You know there is something Flat and sharps on purpose for the sake of style. This is not choir .
OK, then let's wait what happen next.
V
-
Being from a nugu company does not excuse them or the whole project from criticism. If anything it validates the narrative of how shoddy the whole thing is. If you go to a singing contest performing like an amateur, expect to be treated like one. The vocal arrangement is messy and even some of the lines were delivered messy. Compare it to a quality pop song from the west and most normal people will see exactly what i mean (the entire song is in english after all)There was not much invested in this group and it shows. I know what a good Southeast Asian group would look/sound like and this ain't it.This is like the whole Alex from Rania situation. People are so desperate to be validated by the korean industry that they would ignore the red flags surrounding her inclusion in the group (ex. wasn't properly trained/didn't speak korean/treated like a side prop + novelty)
it clearls that you dont know what the project is , their goal is not to vlidated by korean industry , Alex from Rania is different situation he just put and force to fit in Kpop meanwhile Zstar did not copy or pretend to be someone else they make their image ,
What you waiting for is a BOP , if you think that is messy then I don't know what kind of quality you looking for , and No limit was cheesy as 90% of boy groups .
-
I swear I've seen him before
-
We have different opinions and different strokes . their debut song is good if you leveled it up in a nugu company in Korea, zenith is a nugu company in Korea, plus travelling in 3 countries just for the showcase is a good move for a small company the fanbase is growing slowly. Their talents are showing off I can say their talent is on the same level as some top groups now specially the girls.If you really can't see it for yourself then I feel sorry for you. Those groups greatly lack cohesion and even the song is badly mixed. Almost as if the entire thing was rushed together without any proper thought. And once you get past the novelty factor of them being foreigners, nothing about them really stands out as celebrities.
Let me throw back it to you , you didn't see it bcuz you want it and you don't like it. Their not a Big 3 company or medium company to hire some well known composer .
-
Those groups look shoddy and unprofessional. Basically another EXP Edition. Not a serious attempt at making a mainstream group.
I know some people are desperate to see themselves represented in kpop but they wouldn't want to support something that makes them look like jokes. Better to support local idol groups or foreign individuals in kpop groups.
What makes them shoddy? And unprofessional? Bcuz seriously those people said that are damn narroe-minded they dont even bothered to check them out.
-
I wish the best for them. Bashers can eat their ugly face.
-
I'm late but its better than never ..
CONGRATULATIONS BABIES FOR YOUR 1ST AND 2ND WIN IN MUSIC SHOWS , NEXT LETS GO FOR BEST NEW ROOKIE AND NEXT YEAR A DAESANG .. <3
-
In the Philippines it's a bad manners when your wearing a cap while eating. Lolz
-
What happened to Seo Jung?
-
also a signature a combination of these 3 boys
@1:04 - 1:05 ( No limt part )
@1:55 - 1:06
@1:41 - 1:42
with slow motion and soft features like effect ..plzz
thanks in advance
-
hello can anyone here make me a DP of this video with good quality
@4:17 - @4:20 plzz
-
Hello anyone here can help me or give me GIF for my DP and signatures? plzz
-
Save these boys from YG plz! I regret my almost of my faves are in T13 huhhhu
-
1
-
-
hopefully you said goodbye to your loved ones...
plz no
-

The Official Z GIRLS Thread - Asia's Girl Group - Debut on 22nd February with 'What You Waiting For'
in Groups
Posted
Maybe it will less awkward when they visit Philippines since we Filipinos can understand English very well, so its easy to communicate with the members and can go with the flow in the conversation..